The purpose of Treasury’s recently published Quality of Advice Review is to improve the accessibility and affordability of quality financial advice, with the goal of helping all Australians achieve their financial goals and make informed decisions about their finances.
The review was focussed on the regulatory framework that applies to the supply of financial advice. The Review was chaired by Michelle Levy and has been received with strong reactions both positive and negative.
On 15 February, I attended Michelle Levy’s first public appearance to discuss the report at the Actuaries Institute’s Financial advice event in Sydney. It was a lively affair chaired by the new Actuaries Institute president Naomi Edwards, who has direct experience with advice challenges in the superannuation and life insurance industries more generally. The event focused on the impacts of the Report’s recommendations in practice and how this might benefit everyday Australians with a key focus on Superannuation. It included productive Q&A that highlighted some of the concerns people have with the current, and proposed, regulatory requirements.
My impressions from across the range of speakers on stage and from the floor were:
- The current system for the provision of financial advice is not practical or accessible, especially for low to middle-income earners. This is a result of the extremely high regulatory burden financial advisors face, not only in the process of giving advice, but in the cost as well.
- The recommendations in the report open up avenues for the provision of good advice, as it is termed in the report, by expanding the current definition of personal advice.
- The speakers were complimentary of the report, at least as a starting point for discussions around the way forward.
- The issue consumer groups have is where for certain scenarios, the recommendations proposed may lead to members being worse off. Ms Levy’s view was that she expects the recommendations to do the opposite and will leave members better off.
- Hand in hand with the need for advice, is the need for education and financial literacy.
- The complexity of superannuation discourages members.
- It is important for both the price of advice to decrease and general education on superannuation to increase for better outcomes across the board.
Where from here?
It is now in the hands of the Federal Labor Government, who have the power to implement the recommendations in the report. The report will undergo more stress testing and expert analysis to further measure the impact of the proposed changes before full consideration.
We are all well aware of the issues in play, yet every day of inaction worsens the situation as Australians go without the financial advice they need to adequately plan for their goals. There will always be disagreements, and gaps in regulation; however the key focus should be on the net improved outcomes these recommendations will result in.
In my view, the Levy Report has provided some valuable, important recommendations to improve the current regulatory framework. It remains to be seen if the government is ready to carry out these recommendations or if further improvements that address consumer groups’ concerns can be identified.

About the Author:
Sankarshan Muralitharan is an actuarial analyst at McGing and has worked on a number of superannuation fund and life insurance projects where member equity and fairness, linked to member and policyholder best outcomes, are core.